Bryan Cooper

Main Content

Homes for Sale in Little Silver, NJ

With a population of just over 5,800 in an area measuring 3.3 square miles, Little Silver, NJ is a waterfront community that epitomizes small-town living. It sits on the banks of the Shrewsbury River, just four miles from the shores of the Atlantic Ocean.

Entering Little Silver feels like stepping back in time. Residents enjoy downtown parades, shopping in family-owned pharmacies, grabbing a bite to eat at old-timey luncheonettes, and picking up their fresh produce, specialty foods, gifts, plants, and landscaping supplies in a market that’s been owned and operated by the same family for four generations.

No surprise, then, that Little Silver has been singled out as the “#1 Best Place to Raise a Family in Monmouth County, NJ” by the site,


In the 1800s, the area where Little Silver now stands was mostly agricultural land, woods, and saltwater marshes.

Just before the turn of the century, when John Lovett turned tracts of land into a nursery for his seed business supplying shopping catalogs like Sears Roebuck, resort hotels began to pop up in the picturesque peninsula. A dock for steamships built in the 1890s led more visitors to discover Little Silver’s charm.

Although much of Lovett’s farms and nursery is gone with residences taking over, homeowners today still tend to backyard gardens, thanks to the town’s rich and fertile soil.

Homes for sale in Little Silver, NJ

If you want to live in this affluent borough, it offers a limited but top-notch selection of top-tier homes.

You’ll find a custom 8-bedroom gated luxury estate situated on over 8 acres of manicured lawns. A 5-bedroom, single-family home sitting on 2 acres along the Shrewsbury River features a heated pool and a dock. You can also find new construction homes with 4 bedrooms and unobstructed water views.

Townhouses for sale are just as impressive. An available 2-story, 5-bedroom light-filled unit features a vaulted foyer, a wood-burning fireplace, walk-in closets in each room, and a balcony off the master suite overlooking the wooded backyard.

Secure the best property from a limited selection. View more homes for sale in Little Silver, NJ here.

Why live in Little Silver, NJ

“People who move here, stay here,” a resident told The New York Times. It accounts for Little Silver’s small-town vibe, with families staying put for generations. It’s also what attracts out-of-towners into buying a home here and being welcomed by this close-knit community.

Little Silver, NJ is a town for everyone, whether downsizing or upsizing. People who move here say the place makes them feel safe. The schools are also second to none, receiving a grade of A+ from

In addition, there’s a reassuring sense of stability that’s important nowadays. Locals honor their past, as seen in the restoration of The Parker Homestead, one of the first homes erected in 1665. The Little River railroad station, first built in 1875, has likewise been restored and included in the U.S. National Register of Historic Places. Trains coming to and from New York City, which is 50 miles away, stop at the station.

Pastimes harken back to simple pleasures like boating and other water sports. At Dominick F. Santelle Park surrounding Park’s Creek, there’s a boat ramp that allows you to row out to go fishing. Or, depending on public advisories, kids can spend time on the park playground. Or simply watch ducks glide across the placid waters.

Call Colleen to explore your housing options in Little Silver, NJ

If you want to know more about living in New Jersey and Little Silver in particular, talk to local expert, Colleen Meyler. She has lived and worked in this area for over 30 years, assisting her satisfied clientele find their forever homes or sell their empty nests for a place better suited to the next phase of their lives.

Colleen and her team will be happy to help you find the home of your dreams in Little Silver and introduce you to a neighborly community that honors its past and present in equal measure.

Call Colleen Meyler at 732.995.5102 or email ColleenMeyler(at)gmail(dotted)com today. You can also message her here.